Top Sellers: The region's top 50 volume realtors for 2024
May 2025
Here it is, our annual list of the region’s top 50 single-family residential sellers in the five-county area and top 10 commercial sellers.
2024 was another banner year for northern Michigan real estate sales, as reported by The Ticker in January. Residential sales for 2024 in the five-county area more or less followed the same year-over-year price jumps experienced in the last half decade. According to real estate group Aspire North, 2024 closed with an average residential sale of $542,681 and a median sale of $399,975 across 2,506 sales (up from $502,697 and $380,000 in 2,538 sales in 2023).
Editor’s note: For the past eight years the TCBN has published the ranking for single-family residential sales in Grand Traverse, Leelanau, Benzie, Kalkaska and Antrim counties by local sellers. The ranking is based on the official MLS data provided by Realtors to their regional association. TCBN did not receive any MLS database access nor any information directly from Aspire North Realtors or Northern Great Lakes Realtors MLS for these rankings. Data is published as provided with no changes or manipulations. Those with an asterisk, in the top 25 only, are Realtors in 2024 who worked as a “team," where properties sold by 2+ individuals are listed under one person's name.
For commercial-only sales, see the list below.
TOP 2024 SINGLE-FAMLY RESIDENTIAL SELLERS
1. Bob Brick, RE/MAX Bayshore, $97.3m*
2. Don Fedrigon, RE/MAX of Elk Rapids, $56.9m
3. Sam Flamont, The Mitten Real Estate Group, $53.6m*
4. Matthew Dakoske, RE/MAX Bayshore, $47m*
5. Molly Buttleman, Coldwell Banker Schmidt, $46.6m
6. Ranae Ihme, LVR Realty, $41.3m*
7. Linda Schaub, Real Estate One, $37.4m
8. Camille Campbell, Coldwell Banker Schimdt, $34.2m
9. Ann Porter, Real Estate One, $32.1m
10. Christina Ingersoll, RE/MAX Bayshore, $31.4m
11. Michael Annelin, Century 21 Northland, $30.6m
12. Jules Yates, RE/MAX Bayshore, $27.7m*
13. Shawn Schmidt, Coldwell Banker Schimdt, $25.4m
14. Janel Brown, Real Estate One, $24.6m*
15. Kari King, Century 21 Northland, Frankfort, $23.4m
16. Tim Schaub, Schaub Team Premier Realty, $23.3m
17. Kimberly Bork, Venture Properties, $23.3m
18. Jon Zickert, Real Estate One, Beulah/Frankfort, $21.9m
19. Tamara Vomastek, Terra Real Estate, $21.5m
20. Kyle O'Grady, RE/MAX Bayshore, $21.4m
21. TJ Shimek, The Mitten Real Estate Group, $19.9m
22. Erika Nita, @properties Christie's Intl., $19.8m*
23. Jaimie Fellows-Garno, City2Shore Real Estate-NM, $18.5m
24. Jeffrey Rabidoux, Crystal Mountain Realty, $17.9m
25. Carly Petrucci, Coldwell Banker Schmidt, $17.7m
26. Ryan Craig, @properties Christie's Intl., $17.6m
27. Corliss Beuerle, Century 21 Northland, $17.6m
28. Steve Scheppe, Viewpoint Realty, $17.4m
29. Christine Stapleton, Stapleton Realty, $17m
30. Matthew Geib, Viewpoint Realty, $16.9m
31. Ben Street, Coldwell Banker Schmidt, $16.7m
32. Tamara McLeod Helsel, City2Shore Real Estate-NM, $16.6m
33. Ted Schweitzer, Real Estate One, $16.2m
34. Aubrey Vandemark, The Mitten Real Estate Group, $16.1m
35. Gary Scheitler, Paradise Properties USA, $16m
36. Thomas Alflen, EXIT Realty Paramount, $15.5m
37. Robin Vilter, Five Star Real Estate, $15.4m
38. Jonathan Oltersdorf, Oltersdorf Realty, $15.3m
39. Pam DePuy, The Martin Co., $15.1m
40. Erica Mohr, Real Estate One, $14.8m
41. Kathy Wittbrodt, Wittbrodt Waterside Properties, $14.8m
42. Hillary Voight, Five Star Real Estate, $14.7m
43. Jennifer Gaston, RE/MAX Bayshore, $14.6m
44. Tia Rieck, Coldwell Banker Schmidt, $14.5m
45. Debra Hall, Real Estate One, $14m
46. Julia Pietrowicz, Keller Williams NM, $13.9m
47. Jack Lane, Real Estate One, $13.8m
48. Roger Schaub, Schaub Team Premier, $13.8m
49. Toni Morrison, Real Estate One Elk Rapids, $13.8m
50. Mark Hagan, Coldwell Banker Schmidt, $13.6m
TOP 2024 COMMERCIAL SELLERS
1. Dan Stiebel, Coldwell Banker Schmidt, $40.3m
2. Kevin Query, Manitou Commercial Real Estate, $19.1m
3. Kevin Endres, Three West, $13.8m
4. Scott Hardy, Coldwell Banker Schmidt, $10.9m
5. Doug Meteyer, Keller Williams, $9m
6. Alex MacKenzie, Coldwell Banker Schmidt, $8.2m
7. Marty Stevenson, EXIT Realty Paramount, $7.6m
8. Bill Somerville, Three West, $5.5m
9. Carole Higgins, Cygnus Real Estate, $5.2m
10. Sam Flamont, The Mitten Real Estate Group, $4.9m
Sales numbers are commercial sales as entered into MLS and might not reflect commercial leases or commercial vacant land sales, which could alter results significantly.
